About this spot
Benitto Italy in Getsemani serves authentic Italian fare that feels distinctly Colombian rather than generic tourist fare, avoiding the clichés found elsewhere in the city. The kitchen focuses on hearty pastas and rustic pizzas that highlight local ingredients while maintaining traditional European techniques.
💡 Tips before you go
- Ask for extra Parmesan cheese to be grated fresh at the table to elevate the flavor of your pasta dishes.
- Reserve a seat in advance as this Getsemani spot fills up quickly with locals seeking a reliable dinner.
- Save room for their tiramisu, which is made with locally sourced coffee and cream instead of the overly sweet versions common in hotels.
Common Questions
How much does Benitto Italy cost?
Expect to pay between $25 and $45 per person for a main course and dessert, totaling approximately $30-$60 USD depending on wine choices.
Where is Benitto Italy?
Located in the Getsemani neighborhood of Cartagena, near the city center but tucked away from the main tourist drag.
What should I order at an Italian restaurant in Cartagena?
Start with their carbonara or cacio e pepe, which use authentic egg and cheese emulsions rather than cream-based sauces often found in other cities.
About this page
Restaurant: Benitto Italy
Cuisine: Restaurant
Location: Getsemani, Cartagena, Colombia
Source: Curated from local review platforms